Columbus Day Reconsidered: Why It Should Not Be Celebrated

by James
3 views 9 minutes read

Columbus Day should not be celebrated. It’s a controversial topic that has sparked heated debates and divided opinions. But why should we reconsider celebrating this holiday? The answer lies in the historical facts surrounding Christopher Columbus and the devastating consequences of his arrival in the Americas. While Columbus may have been credited with “discovering” America, the truth is far more complex and darker than the sanitized version we were taught in school. In this article, we will delve into the reasons why Columbus Day should not be celebrated and explore alternative ways to honor the history of the Americas.

Columbus Day Reconsidered: Why it Should Not be Celebrated

Columbus Day Should Not Be Celebrated


Columbus Day is a widely celebrated holiday in the United States that commemorates the arrival of Christopher Columbus in the Americas. However, in recent years, there has been a growing movement questioning the celebration and calling for its abolishment. This article aims to explore the reasons why Columbus Day should not be celebrated, delving into historical inaccuracies, the impact on indigenous communities, and the need for a more inclusive and accurate portrayal of history.

Historical Inaccuracies and Misrepresentation

One of the primary reasons why Columbus Day should not be celebrated is the historical inaccuracies and misrepresentation that surround Christopher Columbus. For many years, children were taught that Columbus discovered America and was a heroic figure. However, this narrative is far from the truth.

  • Columbus was not the first person to reach the Americas. Indigenous peoples had already inhabited the land for thousands of years before his arrival. The Vikings, led by Leif Erikson, had established settlements in North America around 500 years before Columbus.
  • Columbus was also not the first European explorer to reach the Americas. John Cabot, an Italian explorer, arrived in North America in 1497, a year before Columbus’ famous voyage.
  • Furthermore, Columbus did not realize that he had reached a new continent. He believed that he had reached Asia and spent his subsequent voyages searching for a route to India.

These distortions in historical facts have perpetuated an inaccurate narrative of Columbus as a heroic explorer, overshadowing the true history of indigenous peoples and their contributions.

Impact on Indigenous Communities

Another crucial aspect to consider is the impact Columbus and subsequent colonization had on indigenous communities. Columbus’ arrival marked the beginning of a brutal era of colonization, resulting in the displacement, enslavement, and genocide of millions of indigenous people.

  • The arrival of European settlers brought diseases, such as smallpox, for which indigenous populations had no immunity. This led to the decimation of entire communities, ultimately leading to the loss of countless lives and cultures.
  • Indigenous peoples were subjected to forced labor, violence, and exploitation under colonial rule. Their land was stolen, and they were treated as inferior, resulting in the loss of sovereignty and traditional ways of life.
  • The celebration of Columbus Day further perpetuates the erasure of indigenous history and the ongoing struggles faced by indigenous communities. It dismisses the atrocities committed during the colonization process, disregarding the pain and suffering inflicted upon indigenous peoples.

The Need for an Inclusive and Accurate Portrayal of History

Instead of celebrating Columbus, it is essential to shift the focus towards a more inclusive and accurate portrayal of history. Recognizing the contributions and resilience of indigenous peoples is crucial in understanding the true history of the Americas.

  • Instead of Columbus, we should celebrate and honor indigenous leaders, activists, and trailblazers who have fought for justice and the preservation of indigenous cultures.
  • By acknowledging the true history of the Americas, we can create a more inclusive society that values and respects the diverse cultures and experiences of all its inhabitants.
  • Revising the curriculum in schools to offer a more comprehensive and accurate portrayal of history, including the perspectives of indigenous peoples, is a necessary step towards fostering understanding and empathy.

In conclusion, Columbus Day should not be celebrated due to the historical inaccuracies and misrepresentation surrounding Christopher Columbus, the devastating impact on indigenous communities, and the need for a more inclusive and accurate portrayal of history. By reevaluating our celebrations and focusing on a more truthful narrative, we can work towards creating a society that values diversity and respects the rights and contributions of all individuals. It is time to recognize the true history of the Americas and honor those who have been marginalized and oppressed for centuries.

Why Christopher Columbus Day Should Not Be Celebrated | Opinions | NowThis

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should Columbus Day not be celebrated?

There are several reasons why some people believe Columbus Day should not be celebrated:

– Christopher Columbus’s arrival in the Americas had devastating consequences for the indigenous people who already inhabited the land, leading to violence, enslavement, and the spread of diseases.

– Columbus’s actions and the subsequent European colonization resulted in the loss of culture, land, and lives of Native American communities.

– Celebrating Columbus Day can be seen as glorifying a figure who played a significant role in the oppression and colonization of indigenous peoples.

– Recognizing the true history of Columbus’s arrival and its impacts can help promote a more equitable and inclusive society.

What are some alternatives to celebrating Columbus Day?

Instead of celebrating Columbus Day, some alternatives include:

– Indigenous Peoples’ Day: Many cities and states have replaced Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples’ Day to honor and recognize the rich history and contributions of indigenous communities.

– Exploration Day: Shifting the focus to celebrating exploration and discovery without solely attributing it to Columbus allows for a broader recognition of various historical figures and events.

– Education and awareness: Using the day to educate oneself and others about the true history of colonization and the experiences of indigenous peoples can be a meaningful way to honor their stories and promote understanding.

Does celebrating Columbus Day contribute to the erasure of indigenous narratives?

Yes, celebrating Columbus Day can perpetuate the erasure of indigenous narratives. By focusing solely on Columbus and his arrival, the complex history and diverse cultures of indigenous peoples can be overlooked. This erasure reinforces a distorted narrative that downplays the experiences, contributions, and resilience of indigenous communities. Moving towards a more inclusive commemoration can help address this issue.

Final Thoughts

Columbus Day should not be celebrated. Despite the historical significance associated with Christopher Columbus, it is important to acknowledge the negative consequences of his actions. Celebrating Columbus Day perpetuates a romanticized and inaccurate view of his voyages, contributing to the erasure of indigenous cultures and the atrocities committed against Native Americans. By doing away with the holiday, society can begin to confront the painful truths of colonization and work towards a more inclusive and honest understanding of our history. It is time to reassess the celebration of Columbus Day and instead promote a more accurate and respectful commemoration of Native American heritage.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.

Adblock Detected

Please support us by disabling your AdBlocker extension from your browsers for our website.